Jump to Navigation
$2.485 Million Medical Malpractice Jury Verdict and Bad Faith Lawsuit Against Largest Medical Professional Liability Insurer in the State of Illinois

Walsh, Knippen, Knight & Diamond, Chtd. proudly announces that after a two week jury trial, Ed Walsh and Brad Pollock received a jury verdict of $2,485,000.00 in Cook County case 00L 10323. The verdict is $1,485,000.00 in excess of the policy limit of insurance available to indemnify the defendant physician.

The insurer for the defendant doctor, Illinois State Medical Inter-Insurance Exchange, is the largest professional medical liability insurance carrier in the state of Illinois. Following the verdict, ISMIE paid its full $1,000,000.00 liability policy limit.

In order to collect the full amount of the verdict and judgment, together with interest and punitive damages, the Firm has filed a "Bad Faith" lawsuit (pdf file) against ISMIE after receiving an assignment of the claim and cause of action from the defendant doctor and his personal attorney.

The defendant doctor was suffering from incurable cancer while the lawsuit was pending; he desired to settle the case. ISMIE refused to discuss settlement of the lawsuit unless the doctor was subjected to a discovery deposition.

The doctor never had the physical or emotional strength to subject himself to a deposition and died during the pendancy of the suit. After his death, ISMIE refused to discuss settlement or offer any money in order to settle the case. The Bad Faith lawsuit is currently pending and being prosecuted in the Circuit Court of Cook County .

Ed, Brad and the Firm were privileged to represent a wonderful 43 year old man who lost total hearing in his left ear and suffers from permanent imbalance as a result of negligently performed outpatient ear surgery.

Ed, Brad and the Firm were successful in accomplishing the outstanding result in the underlying medical malpractice lawsuit for several reasons. The firm has a staff of assistants, paralegals and a legal nurse consultant expert in the prosecution of medical negligence cases. Through detailed medical research, the Firm was able to retain an extremely highly qualified ENT surgeon from the most premier ear clinic in the United States to testify as an expert witness on behalf of their client.

All of the 104 trial exhibits were used and illustrated throughout the trial by way of a PowerPoint® computer graphics presentation. Similarly, Ed illustrated the significant trial exhibits and key jury instructions by way of a PowerPoint® presentation during his closing argument. Finally, all pretrial depositions and daily trial testimony were downloaded to the attorneys' notebook computers and immediately searchable using Summation® litigation support software.

Practice Areas Case Histories

Anderson v. Thompson, MD Circuit Court of Cook County, Illinois $2.5 Million Settlement.

Doe v. SuperFlow Circuit Court of Cook County, Illinois $5.25 Million Settlement

Cann v. Life Products, Inc., Circuit Court of Cook County, Illinois $10 Million Jury Verdict

Bechtol v. Campbell, Circuit Court of Cook County, Illinois $7.3 Million Jury Verdict

Liporini v. Westlake Hospital, Circuit Court of Cook County, Illinois $6.1 Million Award

Kilgore v. Heggen, Circuit Court of Will County, Illinois $5.7 Million Award

LoCoco v. Garbowski, M.D., Circuit Court of Cook County, Illinois $2.6 Million Jury Verdict

Knauerhaze v. Allen, M.D., Circuit Court of Cook County, Illinois $2.485 Million Jury Verdict

Krywokulski v. Wilbur, Circuit Court of Cook County, Illinois $2.2 Million Award

Garcia v. Horwitz, M.D., Circuit Court of Cook County, Illinois $1.775 Million Award

Compton v. Ubilluz, M.D. and Nour, M.D., Circuit Court of DuPage County, Illinois $1.73 Million Jury Verdict

Enyart v. Rahn, MD, Circuit Court of DuPage Country, Illinois $1.550 Million Settlement

Janetis v. Christensen, M.D., Circuit Court of Cook County, Illinois $1.1 Million Award

Licastro v. Rowley, M.D., Circuit Court of DuPage County, Illinois $710,000 Award

Murray v. R. A. Bright Construction Company, Circuit Court of Will County, Illinois $1.9 Million Award

Out of State Automobile Accident - Death, Circuit Court of Cook County, Illinois $1.1 Million Award

Bus/Automobile Collision - Fracture & Hip Dislocation, Circuit Court of DuPage County, Illinois $800,000 Award

Automobile/Van Collision - Herniated Disc, Circuit Court of Cook County, Illinois $480,000 Award

Car/Truck Collision - Fractures, Circuit Court of Kane County, Illinois $420,000 Award

Truck/Automobile Collision - Spleen Injury, Circuit Court of Dupage County, Illinois $245,000 Award

Callahan v. Bernz-O-Matic, Circuit Court of Cook County, Illinois $2.7425 Million Award

Rader v. City of Chicago, Circuit Court of Cook County, Illinois $1.9 Million Award

Personal Injury : Boat : Leg Injury, Circuit Court of Cook County, Illinois $1.5 Million Award

Wrongful Adoption, Circuit Court of DuPage County, Illinois $780,000 Settlement

Walsh, Knippen, Knight & Pollock
Super Lawyers